10 years ago by
A Pianist
I think Alan's book (first book) focuses more on structure and alignment of the hands, and some tricks to get the right feeling of the complex organizations. I guess the "out the back door" technique is more oriented towards muscles activation. Well, I totally agree these are much more important than muscles activation, as my experience could tell. The old Horowitz is probably not very strong in his muscles, and definitely weaker than virtually all young pianists at their 20s. but the excellent coordination counters for it. On the other hand, there're pianists whose motions I think (and hopefully not misjudged) are not particularly efficient, and yet have extremely good technique at the end, rank among the very top (e.g. Kissin. I think he wastes quite some energy on pressing. Or at least it seems so) I think their hands are just extremely powerful, enough to make up for the waste of energy. It would be wonderful if there are more ways, perhaps more general ways, to strengthen our hands. Or perhaps Alan already touched upon what has been known so far?