10 years ago by
A Pianist
what's that exercise you mentioned? Is it in your books? I find that sliding out (toward myself) is easy and never a problem. But what comes out must goes in again!
Maybe it is worth spelling out what i think is going when i slide. Sliding out is easy because the lumbricals is working in sync with my entire hand (which would be moving toward myself) as the key is being played (and hugged!): both draws the finger tips toward me. As the finger plays and eventually reaches the bottom of the key bed,
There are other uses of sliding, like positioning the hand and phrasing, but for me, making my hands more movable is what makes it such a great practice.
But sliding in creates a huge challenge, especially if the friction is high: as the key bed is reached, the forward movement of the hand thrusts the finger forward along the surface of the key. While in sliding out, the finger responds by easing the pressure (exactly what we want!); when we slide in, the fingers (even when passive and exert little pressure on its own) gets pushed into the key, increasing the friction still further. That makes my hands and fingers less movable. Of course this is compensated by the fingers' response to release its pressure on the key. But still it is far from ideal. And I can feel the ease of my sliding out is suddenly hampered when I have to slide in....